My son Michael narrowed his eyes and scowled with concentration. He was standing in front of the open refrigerator, trying to help me figure out dinner on the hottest day of June. “Mom, is there any reason we couldn’t put those leftover red potatoes in a pasta salad?”
I thought for a moment and couldn’t come up with anything more convincing than, “Wouldn’t that make it POTATO salad?”
“Nope,” Michael replied decisively. “Tonight we’re going to pretend those potatoes are actually vegetables.” Since Michael seemed to have a plan, I wasn’t going to argue…especially since the plan looked to be leading to our favorite pasta salad.
This pasta dish is much more method than recipe. One of the great things about this salad is that I don’t need enough of any single ingredient to feed everyone. That’s very helpful in finishing off the tag ends of stuff in the fridge. The whole idea is to creatively use what’s already in the fridge or cupboard. One of the best things about this salad is that none of the veggies are cooked, so this is a great meal when it’s too hot to cook anything.
Here are the things we found to put into our salad. Obviously, what you’ll find in your refrigerator will be different.
Amazing Pasta Salad
- 2 pounds cooked and salted new red potatoes, cut into chunks
- 1 cucumber, cut into chunks
- 1 ½ c. broccoli florets
- 1/3 c. green onions, finely chopped
- ½ c. chopped cilantro
- 2 roma tomatoes, diced
- ¾ c. alfalfa sprouts
- 1 pound imitation crab meat
- 1/3 c. toasted pine nuts
- 1 pound pasta, cooked and drained (I finished off 3 different packages of pasta this time)
After stirring these ingredients so they were thoroughly mixed, we dressed the salad with a mixture of 3 half-empty salad dressing bottles: Caesar dressing, Honey Dijon Onion dressing, and Greek vinaigrette. Every pasta salad we make tastes unique because the bottles that I’m trying to empty are different from one time to the next.
We served the pasta salad in big soup bowls and topped it with shredded parmesan cheese (crumbled feta cheese or grated asiago cheese would also be delicious.) This salad was huge–perfect for the boys who had been at swim practice at 6:20 AM and for the boy who worked all day out in the sun. Definitely scale the ingredient list up or back to make a salad that fits your family’s size.
And sure enough, Michael was right! Those new red potatoes were just perfect and we all pronounced the salad to be the BEST pasta salad we’d ever had.
For more ideas on resourceful pasta salads, visit this post on My Sister’s Kitchen.
Barb
High Country Parent contributors share our experiences and advice, what works for us. We make no guarantees that you will have the same experience or results, and are not always experts. Please consult a professional before making any lifestyle changes- health, dietary, financial, or otherwise. Click here to see our full disclaimer.



Wow, Barb. I bet that will be MY new favorite pasta salad, too! I love how you mixed the salad dressings. When I get to the end of a bottle, I’m usually tired of it, but if you mix them, it makes a whole new taste.